This question can apply equally to individuals and groups. A lot depends on specific needs and medical conditions. Each carrier has the right to choose the level of risk they wish to accept. As such depending on the coverage needed and other factors the same carrier may be a great option or it may be that multiple carriers need to be used. It is important to use an independent broker who can shop multiple carriers and understands the differences in coverage as well as underwriting. Here is more about how it gets determined.
First, you have to decide on the types of coverage you want. Discussing your needs and desired protections with a broker will allow you to map out the slate of coverage you want to get. With that initial step done you can then begin to look at what companies offer the coverage and at what price. The broker will also know and should advise if coupling together one or more of the products will help generate related policy discounts for the insured.
It is typically hard to get, at the best rate all of your coverage from the same carrier. To bring this home, your home, auto, life, health, long term care, disability, and umbrella is typically not available from a single carrier. When it is, the carrier is not providing the best coverage and best price for each and every one of the products because there is no carrier leading in each product. Thus, you could find yourself overpaying quite a bit for less than the best coverage for your specific needs. Discounts aside, and even just dealing with a single agent are all great but it is probably not the best deal for you.
It may be possible to pair a few of the plan Health-Life related types together with one carrier and secure some discounts. Similarly family discounts may be available from some carriers. Medicare Supplements are one area where the couple’s discount is prevalent. Some mutual companies, because the policy owner is also an owner of the mutual company, offer multi-policy discounts as well. Knowing this and already knowing your slate of needed coverage, a great broker will help you pick the right plans based on your needs while at the same time looking for multi-policy discounts that enhance the cost effectiveness of the coverage you do end up buying.
The next step in the process of determining for you, all from one or best from different carriers approach is best, is assessing your underwriting status. You will need to share medical history with your broker so they can use the information to assess underwriting status with each carrier with a policy that otherwise meets your needs. Then where there are several policies, it moves to the point that the broker is assessing pricing, and cost effectiveness of the coverage.
If by chance the cost effective policies for you are all with the same carrier great. If not then you will want to compare the price of going all with one carrier and decide if the extra cost is worth any additional administrative efforts you incur. This is where we separate out group from Indivdual policies just a bit. The additional administration for an individual policy holder of several policies at the same carrier vs. administration of several policies by a single carrier is very different.
In most cases with Indivdual policies you will get separate bills, or have separate bank drafts for each of the policies regardless of how many are owned. This all has to do with accounting by the carriers. Thus, if you are not saving by having the policies all with a single carrier there ends up no real benefit to doing so. When you can have more cost effective coverage spread over different carriers and still pay the same number of bills or have the same number of bank drafts administratively you are pretty much equal.
For groups because of their larger size and economies of scale working in their favor many carriers will consolidate several polices into one or two bills each month. With this groups may find that the ease in administration is worth a bit of extra cost. This is especially true when you are able to secure several policy elements for employees off of a single application. When you begin to bog down in the Human Resources realm completing several applications for disability, life, dental, medical, and any other insurance related benefit the efficiencies of a single or two applications becomes evident.
Typically with the very large carriers using them to administer several lines of business will almost always generate some additional savings. There are several reasons for this, but one of the biggest is administrative ease on their end. They also know that usually when they provide a slate of benefits packaged together they will be able to work the economics to retain the client longer than if there is only one benefit sold.
In the end on the individual side it is usually best to select the most cost effective set of plans based on your needs. Unless it creates a significant administrative burden to have the plans with multiple carriers you should use the best plans for you based on your needs. For groups more often than not a single or perhaps a couple of carriers typically is the best option. We can offer you many different solutions when you work with us. If you need Life Insurance in Houston we are here to help you.